How to Choose the Right Shopify Agency for Your Ecommerce Business

The Best Payment Gateways

This sponsored placement is paid for by our partners.

Sell more in-store. Unified checkout, synced inventory, and effortless payments.

Learn More

The payment system that powers sales. Faster transactions, flexible hardware & transparent pricing.

Learn More

Grow online with global payments, instant payouts, and powerful developer-ready tools.

Learn More

So much hinges on choosing the right Shopify agency for your ecommerce business. It may very well be the most important decision a business can make when launching, migrating, or scaling an online store.

The Shopify agency of your choice will play a role in how your online store will look and function, including how well it converts customers, how fast your site loads, and even how scalable it is as you grow. A great Shopify agency will have had years of expertise and a track record of success in their portfolio, proving that they have what it takes to not just build you a Shopify website, but they’ll be able to help you construct a revenue-generating online store for your brand.

But how do you choose the right Shopify agency? How do you find a Shopify agency that will perfectly match the requirements of your online business?

In this Shopify guide, we will walk you through how to evaluate a Shopify agency the right way, using research-backed advice and industry best practices, so you’ll be able to vet your very own Shopify agency like a pro.

Make sure to check out our easy-to-digest Shopify Agency Evaluation Checklist at the bottom of this article.

Work with the Experts. Get a FREE QUOTE and discover how Ecommerce Pro can bring your Shopify store to life. 

1. Start With Your Business Goals

Everything starts with understanding the full scope of your business goals and requirements. Not having a clear outline of your business needs is the equivalent of shopping for a Shopify agency in the dark. You’ll pay more than you planned or end up with the wrong result. So before searching for and evaluating agencies, clearly outline your needs.

Ask yourself:

• Are you building a new Shopify store, upgrading your business, or migrating from WooCommerce, Magento, or another platform?
• Do you need just an online catalog, or complex features (subscriptions, custom checkout, B2B wholesale, product configurators)? Determine all the features you want your store to have.
• Do you need one-time development, or ongoing optimization and support?
• What’s your priority: branding & design, conversion optimization, technical customization, or scalability? Scope out all of your requirements.

Clarity on your objectives helps you choose an agency that doesn’t just deliver a website, but delivers what matters to your brand and the online experience you are trying to create.

2. Look for Shopify-Verified Expertise

Now that you have determined what your brand needs, it’s time to shop around for the right Shopify agency for your business.

This is where your powers of discernment really come in handy—remember, a great-looking agency business website doesn’t automatically mean great Shopify expertise.  You’re going to have to dig a little deeper in choosing an agency that is Shopify certified, one that has a solid track record in demonstrating specialization in the Shopify ecosystem.

Check for Shopify Certifications

Shopify Partner or Shopify Plus Partner (enterprise-level) status is a strong signal of platform knowledge and ecosystem competency. A Shopify Partner is an individual or an agency that has been certified by Shopify, vetted for their proven results, and advanced Shopify skills. You can find certified Shopify Partners on the Shopify Partner Directory.

Confirm Their Shopify Track Record

Ask what percentage of their work is Shopify. Some agencies “dabble” in Shopify; others fully specialize in it. Specialists will understand Liquid (Shopify’s templating language), Shopify APIs, app development, and the nuances of ecommerce operations. Go for partners that work exclusively with the Shopify platform, as this gives you an idea of the scope of their expertise.

3. Evaluate Real Case Studies

Screenshots of beautiful modern websites may be compelling, but this tells you nothing of how the store performs. When reviewing an agency’s portfolio, you need to go in-depth and check those live links from their established bodies of work.

This is the part where you explore their real-life work, so click through their established client websites, explore those pages, the checkout process, and how quickly pages load. Ask yourself, are you satisfied with the look and feel of the websites they have made for other brands?

Moreover, ask to check out:

• Before/after data (conversion improvements, site speed, revenue growth)
• Industry-specific examples (e.g., fashion, beauty, electronics, food & beverage)
• Migration success stories

Industry specialists advise looking for measurable results, not just visuals.

Ecommerce Pro tip: Prioritize agencies that can talk about real business outcomes, not just design aesthetics.

More from the ECP Blog: How to Create a High-Converting Shopify Site

4. Check Their Design, UX, and Technical Capabilities

Now that you’ve seen real results from their portfolio, it’s vital to note that a good Shopify agency must do more than create a nice-looking storefront. They need to build a high-performing ecommerce experience designed to convert shoppers into paying customers. This requires the right balance of skill. Your chosen Shopify agency needs to be adept in brand-focused design, user experience (UX) strategy, and technical engineering.

Here are the areas you need to focus on:

Evaluate Their Branding & UX Strategy

A visually attractive store means nothing if shoppers don’t know where to click, can’t find products, or abandon their carts out of frustration. Make sure the agency demonstrates a clear understanding of:

• Visual hierarchy (what customers notice first)
•  Mobile-first layouts (since most sales happen on mobile)
•  Shopper psychology & conversion principles (what motivates purchases)

Conversion-focused UX is one of the biggest contributors to ecommerce revenue growth, so look for partners who emphasize performance alongside aesthetics.

Assess Their Technical Expertise

Your business needs may go beyond Shopify’s out-of-the-box features, and your agency should be ready to support that by providing you with the brand experience you imagined. Ask whether they can handle your requirements, which you will have determined already in Step 1. Here are some examples to discuss with potential Shopify Partners:

• Custom Liquid development (Shopify’s native templating language)
• App integrations or custom app development
• Custom checkout flows
• Speed & SEO optimization
• Headless or API-based architecture for scaling

5. Evaluate Communication, Pricing & Project Management

The 5th step involves assessing professionalism and work ethic. Even the most technically skilled agency can become a liability to your brand if communication is unclear or project management is disoriented. Before hiring, ensure your Shopify partner can clearly explain their step-by-step process. They also need to be able to give you clear pricing and set timelines for milestones in the project. The right Shopify agency will treat your project like a partnership, keeping you informed and in the loop at every step of the project.

Here is what to expect:

Detailed Proposals

A reliable agency provides a clear, itemized proposal outlining all aspects of the project, including design and development, content setup, app integrations, Q/A testing, and post-launch support.

Note: Avoid agencies that give vague quotes or promise results without specifics. All processes and pricing need to be clear to you.

Clear Timelines & Milestones

The right Shopify agency should be able to provide you with a structured project timeline with clearly defined phases such as development and integrations, QA testing, and launch deployment. These timelines should include deliverables that are up for your approval, so you know exactly what happens, when it happens, and what’s expected from both sides. You’ll also be able to assess deliverables across the timeline.

Quality Assurance (QA)

A trustworthy Shopify agency should clearly explain how they test your store before launch, including cross-device and cross-browser checks, speed optimization, and bug fixes. Proper QA ensures that your store performs smoothly for customers and helps you avoid costly fixes after launch. The right Shopify agency will ensure everything is smooth sailing before you take your store live.

6. Evaluate Possible Long-Term Partnership

When looking to hire the right Shopify agency for your online store, it’s best to approach the search with long-term partnerships in mind, and that’s because your online store and its needs aren’t static. It needs updates, feature enhancements, UX testing, and maintenance. The right Shopify agency will have retainer services that will allow you to benefit from an ongoing support program and not just a one-time build.

Look for agencies that offer clear post-launch plans and long-term support. Solid retainer programs are billed monthly, even hourly. This ensures you can continue to improve performance, boost conversion, and keep your business competitive without scrambling to find help last minute in the event of an error. Ongoing support is about staying proactive and keeping your site optimized month after month.

Look for agencies that provide:

• Retainer services
• Maintenance & bug support
• Speed monitoring
• Analytics reporting & conversion optimization
• SEO improvements
• Scalability planning (Shopify Plus, headless, international expansion)

Red Flags: When NOT to Hire a Shopify Agency

Now that you know what qualities to look for in your search for the right Shopify agency, it’s also important to know how to spot the red flags. Remember that, even if an agency looks impressive on paper or if they have a shiny website, certain warning signs can signal future problems.
A poorly chosen partner can lead to missed deadlines, unexpected costs, weak store performance, or a site that fails to convert after launch. Before signing any contract, watch out for these red flags:

• Offer vague quotes or extremely low prices (often causes scope issues later)
• Use generic templates without customization
• Can’t explain their QA/test process
• Have no proven Shopify-specific case studies
• Don’t provide post-launch support

These are common causes of failed ecommerce builds and budget overruns. And while it may be tempting to go with Shopify partners offering low prices, these are the agencies that offer shortcuts that will cost you later.

Shopify Agency Evaluation Checklist

More from the ECP Blog: Shopify vs Shopify Plus: How to Choose the Right Plan

Conclusion: You’re Choosing a Growth Partner

A Shopify store isn’t just a design project; you’re building a home for your brand online. Your Shopify website needs to accurately represent your brand and house all the features and functions you need to be able to convert browsers into customers.

The right agency should understand your brand and its goals. Moreover, they need to have proven expertise on the Shopify platform, be able to deliver measurable results, and offer long-term growth support.

So, invest the time to evaluate agencies properly and remember that the cost of choosing wrong is much higher than the cost of choosing right.

Work With the Experts: Ecommerce Pro

At Ecommerce Pro, we specialize in helping brands build high-performing Shopify stores that not only look great but also convert. Our team combines Shopify expertise, a results-driven approach, and ongoing support to ensure your store grows with your business.

Ready to take your online store to the next level? Get a FREE QUOTE and see how Ecommerce Pro can help turn your Shopify vision into a reality.